![]() |
|
|||
|
In your opinion, which of these 3 directors is superior when it comes to making horror movies?
1. John Carpenter - Directed the following: Halloween The Fog Christine The Thing Prince of Darkness In the Mouth of Madness Vampires Village of the Damned Cigarette Burns 2. John Landis - He's directed the following: An American Werewolf in London Twilight Zone: The Movie Innocent Blood Deer Woman 3. David Cronenberg - He directed: Rabid Shivers The Brood Scanners Videodrome The Fly Dead Ringers The Dead Zone |
|
|||
|
While some of the artsy crowd might vote for Cronenberg, I would have to give John Carpenter the nod. All 3 are excellent (Werewolf in London was a freakin scream), but I believe Carpenter's films have had a greater impact on modern filmmaking.
That, and I always thought Kurt Russell was pretty hunky for an older guy. That being said, I thought Cigarette Burns sucked a high hard one. Yuck. |
|
|||
|
John Carpenter...without a doubt. The Thing and Big Trouble in Little China are my two all-time favorites.
His career has really run out of steam, but he was a force of nature during the 80s. |
|
|||
|
Cronenberg wins on originality. Videodrome was reall nice and The Fly is one of best movies ever. Carpenter was good, but all his movies had that same cheap-sounding music. And who can forget Michael Ironside getting his head blown up in Scanners?
|
|
|||
|
I'd vote for Cronenberg if not for Halloween, which I contend is a masterpiece far beyond just the horror genre.
__________________
Fantasy Sports |
|
|||
|
Has to be Carpenter. The Fog scared em witless as a kid and the rest of his work is great too.
Last edited by Groovy_Movie; 11-24-2007 at 10:57 PM. |
|
|||
|
Quote:
|
|
|||
|
My favorite isn't on the list but I'll go with Cronenberg on this one.
http://www.nocountrymovie.com/game.php |
|
|||
|
Why no mention of Alfred Hitchcock?...
__________________
Sexy Female Celebrity Features Hot Sexy Male Celebrities Celebrities in DVD TV Shows |
|
|||
|
The list was about which of the three was the better horror director, not who was the greatest of all time. As much as I like all these guys, I never claimed that they could hold a candle to Hitch.
Hitchcock's on a whole other level. |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
The Cinema Threads Movie Forum is Copyright 2006 - 2009 by Small World Marketing. All Rights Reserved.
The Cinema Threads Movie Forum is not affiliated with any other movie forum, any particular movie, or and representatives of any other movie forums or movies. The Cinema Thread Movie Forum is provided for the entertainment and education of anyone who wants to discuss movies on the Internet. Registration at the Cinema Threads Movie Forum has always been and will always be free. The Cinema Thread Movie Forum is part of a network of websites devoted to entertainment. Some other movie related sites in our network feature Good Movies, Top 100 Movies, and Movie Quotations.
The Cinema Threads Movie Forum is provided as is without any kinds of warranties or guarantees. Enjoy the forum, and discuss movies with us.